Many MSP owners find themselves in a hybrid mindset managing their accounting records on the accrual basis while filing on the cash basis. It’s a setup that can deliver the best of both worlds: clear, accurate management data alongside strategic tax flexibility. But to make it work, you need to understand the differences and manage your books accordingly.
At Red Earth CPA, we work with MSPs who want the visibility of accrual reporting without giving up the tax advantages of cash-basis filing. Here’s how we recommend approaching it.
Accrual vs. Cash Basis: The Core Difference
Accrual accounting records income when it’s earned and expenses when they’re incurred, regardless of when the cash changes hands. Cash accounting records income when payment is received and expenses when they are paid.
For example, you bill a client $5,000 in December. On the accrual basis, it’s December’s income. On the cash basis, it’s only income when the client pays in January. This timing difference has a ripple effect on financial reporting, profitability tracking, and tax liability.
Why Many MSPs File Taxes on Cash Basis
Most small-to-midsize MSPs choose cash-basis tax filing for its practical benefits. It allows for tax planning flexibility; shifting year-end invoices or prepaying expenses can reduce taxable income. It prevents paying taxes on receivables you haven’t yet collected. And it aligns your tax bill with actual cash flow, not paper profits.
The trade-off? The IRS’s view of your business’s profitability may be very different from the reality you see in your management reports. This can cause confusion if you’re trying to reconcile your tax return with internal financial statements.
The Management Value of Accrual Books
Even if you file on the cash basis, accrual accounting provides a truer operational picture. It matches revenue with the costs incurred to generate it, giving you more realistic profit margins. It also improves month-to-month and year-to-year comparability, which is especially important for recurring revenue MSPs. Trends become clearer, and decisions can be based on a more accurate view of performance.
MSP Nuances: Deferred Revenue
For MSPs with managed service agreements, deferred revenue is a key concept. You may invoice quarterly or annually in advance. On the accrual basis, those upfront payments sit on the balance sheet as a liability until earned. Each month, you recognize a portion as revenue.
On the cash basis, the full payment is recorded as income when received, making some months look artificially strong and others unusually weak. Accrual accounting smooths that income over the contract term, making your performance tracking much more reliable.
Accruing Costs vs. Expensing Immediately
Accrual accounting affects the expense side too. Interest is recorded when owed, not when paid. Payroll earned in December but paid in January still belongs in December’s books. Annual software renewals are recorded as assets and expensed monthly, not all at once.
On the cash basis, these costs hit when the payment is made, which can distort profit reporting, making one month look inflated and the next month look unreasonably low.
The Smoothness Factor
Cash basis can create lumpy financial results, big revenue spikes after annual billings or expense dips when payments are delayed. Accrual accounting smooths the ride, making growth trends easier to spot, gross margin more accurate, and profitability analysis more reliable.
For MSP owners making strategic decisions about hiring, pricing, or capital investments, smooth and comparable data is gold.
Keep It Simple Without a Full-Time Controller
Full accrual accounting, especially under GAAP, can be overkill for MSPs without a dedicated controller. While you could accrue wages, payroll taxes, benefits, prepaid insurance, property taxes, and more, it often adds complexity without proportional insight.
Instead, focus on the areas with the greatest impact on smoothing income and producing useful monthly reports:
-
Invoicing & Accounts Receivable – Record revenue when it’s earned.
-
Accounts Payable – Record expenses when they’re incurred.
-
Deferred Revenue – Spread prepaid client revenue over the service period.
By concentrating on these three, you can achieve most of the benefits of accrual-based management reporting without drowning in detail. Your CPA can make additional adjustments at year-end as needed.
Practical Takeaways
Managing on the accrual basis while filing on the cash basis is about combining clarity with flexibility. Use accrual for internal KPIs like MRR, gross margin, and EBITDA. They’re far more meaningful when smoothed. Understand that deferred revenue is a visibility tool, not a tax trick. And accrue key costs like interest, wages, and prepaids so they appear in the period they truly relate to.
When you know where to apply accrual adjustments, and where to keep it simple, you’ll have the data you need to run your MSP effectively, while keeping the tax advantages of cash-basis filing.